Complete Suite: all 12 tools. 6 Premium desks inside.All 12 tools $606.98 one by one

$606.98 one by one $97 once Save $509.98Get the SuiteGet it
ProEA Lab · MT5, TradingView and trading research · Evidence standards
Systems

Engulfing Volume Desk: a good 2025–26 on gold's 4-hour chart, and the 2023–24 test it failed

The plain engulfing-with-volume rule on OANDA gold 4H: 83 trades and a gain after costs and financing in 2025–26, then 134 trades and a loss on the 2023–24 history we had held back. Every number, how we measured it, and what changed along the way.

PL · 7 min read
Native TradingView capture, OANDA:XAUUSD on the 4-hour chart with Engulfing Volume Desk v0.6.1: engulfing setups labelled by side and volume grade, such as Short · Low volume and Long · High volume, with TradingView's Stop and Target exit markers.

Short version: traded as a 4-hour swing plan on OANDA gold, the plain rule — a confirmed engulfing candle in the direction of the 200 EMA, a breakout entry, a stop beyond both candles, a 2R target — finished 2025–26 ahead by USD 862 on a USD 10,000 account after stressed costs and overnight financing, with a deepest equity fall of 4.2%. We then ran it, once, on 2023–24, a stretch of history we had kept aside for exactly that purpose. There it lost USD 950 under the same costs, and it lost before financing too. Same rule, same settings, two different markets.

This article is where the numbers live. The desk page carries none of them.

The rule

On a closed candle: the body is larger than the previous candle's body, covers both ends of it and has the opposite colour (bullish engulfing after a red candle, bearish after a green one). Longs need a close above a rising 200 EMA, shorts a close below a falling one. Relative volume is the candle's volume over the average of the previous twenty: Low below 1.0, Medium from 1.0, High from 1.5. Every grade is accepted; the grade is recorded, not used as a filter. How that rule compares with the most-boosted engulfing scripts on TradingView, most of which mark the live candle: best engulfing candle indicators, code-read.

The plan is fixed at the close of the engulfing candle: entry one tick beyond the previous candle's high (long) or low (short) as a stop order, or at the next bar if the close is already through; stop one tick beyond both candles; target at twice the planned risk; the pending order expires after five candles or if the stop is touched first. Risk is 0.5% of equity per setup, with the position capped at 95% of equity. One setup at a time. These are the release's defaults.

How we measured

  • Market: OANDA:XAUUSD on TradingView, 4-hour candles. Every number below is TradingView's own Strategy Tester ledger, read trade by trade from the native report. Account USD 10,000.
  • Costs: base — USD 0.30 commission per ounce per fill and 100 ticks (USD 0.10) slippage on market and stop orders; stressed — USD 0.60 and 200 ticks.
  • Overnight financing (TradingView does not charge it): for every New York 17:00 rollover a position is held through, position value × the annual rate ÷ 365, Wednesdays counted three times, charged to longs and shorts alike, a full day per rollover. The rate is 6.5% a year at base and 10% stressed, set from OANDA's published method for gold (the tom-next swap rate plus a 1% admin fee) with US policy rates at their 2023–24 peak, and no short credit.
  • Two periods: 2025-02-20 to 2026-09-28 (signal closes) is the one we developed on. 2023-03-01 to 2024-12-31 was set aside in an earlier round and opened once, after the rule and every setting were fixed in writing.

2025–26: the period we developed on

TradingView Strategy Tester, Engulfing Volume Desk on OANDA:XAUUSD 4H, signal closes 2025-02-20 to 2026-09-28, stressed costs, before financing: 83 trades, total P&L +1,085.85 USD, max drawdown 4.17%, 38 of 83 profitable, profit factor 1.436
TradingView Strategy Tester, stressed costs, before financing (TradingView does not model it). The date range in the header is the chart's loaded history; trades are limited to the research window.
TradesBefore financingFinancingAfter financingDeepest fallWonProfit factor
Base costs83+1,203.69−146.12+1,057.584.02%45.8%1.49
Stressed costs83+1,085.85−223.61+862.244.17%45.8%1.44

Under stress, after financing: longs 57 trades, +632.96; shorts 26, +229.28. February–December 2025 +758.24 (45 trades); January–September 2026 +104.00 (38). Without its five best trades the period still ends +308.79.

2023–24: the history we had held back

TradingView Strategy Tester, Engulfing Volume Desk on OANDA:XAUUSD 4H, signal closes 2023-03-01 to 2024-12-31, stressed costs, before financing: 134 trades, total P&L −523.10 USD, max drawdown 8.69%, 47 of 134 profitable, profit factor 0.868
Same settings and costs, the 2023–24 window, run once.
TradesBefore financingFinancingAfter financingDeepest fallWonProfit factor
Base costs134−147.72−283.13−430.856.62%35.1%0.96
Stressed costs134−523.10−427.14−950.248.69%35.1%0.87

Under stress, after financing: longs 97 trades, −29.26; shorts 37, −920.98. March–December 2023 −371.72 (62 trades); 2024 −578.52 (72). Without its five best trades: −1,412.25. The loss is not a financing artefact: the rule lost before financing in both cost settings.

What the volume grade did

TradingView splits each period by the label on the entry (stressed costs, before financing). In 2025–26, Low-volume longs (+486.21), High-volume longs (+384.62) and Low-volume shorts (+384.46) carried the gains, while Medium-volume entries and High-volume shorts lost a little. In 2023–24 the High-volume shorts — the setups "volume confirmation" is supposed to favour — were the biggest losing group (−389.18), High-volume longs lost too (−221.31), and the only group that gained was Low-volume longs (+497.99). In this test the grade described the candle; it did not tell good setups from bad ones.

Holding overnight versus flat before the rollover

We also ran the same rule closing every position before the 17:00 New York rollover (and only accepting setups early enough to allow that). On 4-hour candles that leaves few trades: 35 in 2025–26 (+150.43 stressed) and 75 in 2023–24 (−350.12). Holding through the rollover was the better choice in 2025–26 and the worse one in 2023–24.

How we got here

This was the sixth round of tests on this idea, all on gold, and the earlier ones count:

  • Rounds 1–4 (15-, 30- and 60-minute charts). After costs the rule was close to break-even or losing on these charts; commission and slippage alone were 9–18% of the typical risk per trade. A retest entry, a trend-efficiency context, an entry router, a rollover cutoff and a cost screen each changed the results, but no version was positive in every period with enough trades.
  • Round 5. We screened 26 variants offline with a simulator that reproduces TradingView's fills trade for trade, picked one by a rule written in advance, and it failed on TradingView. The cause was ours: the offline 4-hour candles had been assembled incorrectly from hourly data.
  • Round 6. The original rule on the 4-hour chart, as above. One thing changed between rounds 5 and 6, and we chose it after seeing 2025–26: the financing charge. Earlier rounds charged USD 5 per ounce per night — roughly 46–91% a year at these gold prices, and not based on any broker. Under that charge 2025–26 was about flat (+7.15 stressed) and 2023–24 lost USD 4,217.85. We replaced it with the published-method rate above before opening 2023–24. The 2023–24 result does not depend on that choice.

What you can take from it

  • On gold's intraday charts, the classic engulfing-with-volume rule didn't clear its costs in our data.
  • On the 4-hour chart it did well in 2025–26 and badly in 2023–24. Our reading: the rule follows what gold happened to do, rather than holding an edge that carries across years.
  • Relative volume is worth seeing on the chart. As a filter, it didn't help here.
  • If you add the desk to a 4-hour gold chart with its defaults, TradingView's report covers everything your plan loads — on ours, January 2023 to now — and shows a positive total before financing, because 2025–26 outweighs 2023–24. Set the window you care about, add your broker's real costs, and account for financing yourself.

Limits

One market, one feed, one timeframe, a default OHLC fill model without intrabar detail, and financing modelled from a published method rather than an account statement. Two periods are two samples of history, not a forecast. Nothing here is advice to trade this rule.

Source: Engulfing Volume Desk v0.6.1 (SHA-256 844c5de3…c4b09c). The measurements ran on v0.5.1 (3919ec52…40379e) with identical trading logic; v0.6.1 changes the title, the default research window and the chart labels, and reproduces both ledgers exactly on TradingView.

Continue reading

Best Intraday and Day Trading Indicators on TradingView (2026), Code-Read.

We read the code of the 12 most-boosted open-source intraday and scalping scripts on TradingView, none skipped: what each calls a signal, whether it waits for the candle to close, whether it gives a stop and a target, and what it alerts. Then the parts intraday adds: where the day starts on NSE's clock, what repaints on a 1-minute chart, and what one scalp costs in fees, worked by hand from a broker's own charges page.

Oct 29 · ProEA Lab

Explainer cover titled Best intraday indicators, code-read: a table of the eight most-boosted open-source TradingView intraday and scalping scripts with ticks, crosses and halves for three checks. Only ITG Scalper and the Super Scalper strategy decide on a closed candle, no script gives a stop and a target, and six send alerts of their own.

Does Turtle Trading Still Work? The 20/10 Breakout, Tested Once on 2026 Crypto

Breakaway Desk Premium's Trend Radar uses the Turtles' 20 and 10 lengths, counted in 4-hour candles, with a 2N-style stop, long only, on six crypto perpetuals. We picked it on 2021–23, confirmed it on 2025 and ran it once on 2026. Here are the rules beside the originals, every period, and the fall.

Oct 29 · ProEA Lab

Cover titled Does turtle trading still work? It charts the cumulative R of the 137 final-test trades from January to August 2026, rising to +11.7R on 8 January, sliding to −49.0R on 12 August, a fall of 60.7R, then climbing in late August.

TradersPost vs PickMyTrade vs CrossTrade: Which TradingView Bridge for Your Broker

All three turn a TradingView alert into a broker order. They differ in what you pay per account, which brokers they reach and where they run. Each company's facts from its own pages (TradersPost read 29 October 2026, PickMyTrade and CrossTrade re-read 11 November 2026), priced for five common setups.

Oct 29 · ProEA Lab

Explainer cover titled TradersPost vs PickMyTrade vs CrossTrade: a table of five setups priced per month on each bridge, from one futures account to Rithmic accounts in NinjaTrader 8, with three steps underneath: count your accounts, check your broker, test on paper first.