We haven't run money through any of the three. ProEA is an affiliate of all three: TradersPost, PickMyTrade and CrossTrade may each pay us if you subscribe through a link labelled as ours. They pay different rates, so the comparison uses only each company's own listed brokers and prices, and it comes out the same whichever one pays us.
TradersPost's pages read 29 October 2026; PickMyTrade's and CrossTrade's read 11 November 2026.
How a TradingView alert becomes a broker order
The alert calls a webhook URL; a bridge at that URL holds your broker connection and places the order.
What you need on TradingView's side
Webhook alerts are on TradingView's paid plans (Essential, Plus, Premium, Ultimate), not on Basic, per its pricing table, and TradingView sends them only from an account with two-factor authentication on (its webhook page). Each bridge reads its own message format: the webhook JSON builder builds and checks it for all three.
Which bridge reaches which broker
List price a month for one live account and for five under one login; “Not listed” means that company's own pages don't name the broker.
| Broker | TradersPost, 1 / 5 | PickMyTrade, 1 / 5 | CrossTrade, 1 / 5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tradovate | $49 / $89 | $50 / $50 | $29 / $29 |
| NinjaTrader | $49 / $89 | $50 / $50 | $29 / $29 |
| Rithmic (prop firm) | Not listed | $50 / $50 | $29 / $29 |
| ProjectX (prop firm) | $49 / $89 | $50 / $50 | Not listed |
| Interactive Brokers | $49 / $89 | $50 / $50 | Not listed |
| TradeStation | $49 / $89 | $50 / $50 | Not listed |
| tastytrade | $49 / $89 | Not listed | Not listed |
| Alpaca | $49 / $89 | Not listed | Not listed |
| Robinhood | $49 / $89 | Not listed | Not listed |
| Webull | $49 / $89 | Not listed | Not listed |
| E*TRADE | $49 / $89 | Not listed | Not listed |
| Tradier | $49 / $89 | $50 / $50 | Not listed |
| Coinbase, Kraken, Bybit or Binance | $49 / $89 | Not listed | Not listed |
| TradeLocker or Match-Trader | Not listed | $50 / $50 | Not listed |
Where these come from
TradersPost: TradersPost's pricing page and connection pages; extra live accounts are $10 a month each on top of the plan. PickMyTrade: its pricing pages for Tradovate and for its other brokers, and its broker list: $50 a month, $135 a quarter or $500 a year per broker login, with unlimited accounts under that login. CrossTrade: CrossTrade's pricing page and broker guide: Standard $29 a month with unlimited accounts; its copier and Account Manager need Pro, $49.
TradingView to Tradovate automation
All three reach Tradovate from the cloud. Cheapest at list for one account: CrossTrade, $29 a month; for five under one login: CrossTrade, $29 a month.
What each one's page says about Tradovate
CrossTrade: “Tradovate is fully supported, and the webhook destination is included with every plan”, linked with no desktop add-on; its Tradovate copier, Account Manager and REST API need Pro. PickMyTrade: Tradovate has its own app at pickmytrade.trade, apart from its other brokers at pickmytrade.io, and “a second broker login needs its own subscription”. TradersPost: a Starter plan covers one live account, and each extra one is a $10 add-on; its Tradovate page says Tradovate's paid API Access add-on isn't required. To build the message, see the PickMyTrade, CrossTrade and TradersPost builder pages.
TradingView to NinjaTrader
With NinjaTrader 8 left running: CrossTrade, $29 a month. Cloud only: TradersPost, $49 a month, through the account's Tradovate login.
The two routes
CrossTrade works through an add-on inside NinjaTrader 8: “NinjaTrader and the CrossTrade NT8 Add-On must stay open and connected on a Windows computer or VPS”, and any account type NinjaTrader holds can take the alert (its webhook page). TradersPost's NinjaTrader connection runs on Tradovate, with your NinjaTrader username and password. PickMyTrade has no NinjaTrader 8 add-on: its page says NinjaTrader accounts that log in through Tradovate work with its Tradovate integration.
TradingView to Rithmic
Cloud only: PickMyTrade, $50 a month per Rithmic login. With NinjaTrader 8 running: CrossTrade, $29 a month. TradersPost has no Rithmic connection.
What that means for a Rithmic prop account
PickMyTrade lists Rithmic among the brokers on pickmytrade.io, a separate app and subscription from its Tradovate one. CrossTrade names Rithmic only as a connection inside NinjaTrader 8, so NinjaTrader has to be open, and NinjaTrader 8 holds one Rithmic connection per instance. Several logins are several PickMyTrade subscriptions, or several NinjaTrader installations with CrossTrade; CrossTrade's price doesn't change with the account count, and copying your own trades to another NinjaTrader 8 machine (Signal Share) needs Elite to broadcast. The CrossTrade plan picker maps that to a plan.
TradingView to TopstepX or ProjectX
TradersPost and PickMyTrade list a ProjectX connection; CrossTrade's Topstep page says it “does not connect to TopstepX”. For a TopstepX account, Topstep's own rule comes before any bridge:
The conditions each bridge states
TradersPost's ProjectX page says a take profit or stop loss can't be sent with the entry, and that you need your own ProjectX API subscription ($29 a month “as of this writing”). PickMyTrade lists ProjectX and TopstepX on pickmytrade.io, and places orders through your own TopstepX API key. So the $1 between their list prices decides nothing: compare those conditions, after Topstep has answered.
Prop firm accounts: connecting isn't permission
Both bridges say it themselves: a bridge that connects to a prop account doesn't mean the firm allows automation.
Their own words
PickMyTrade: “Technical connectivity does not establish a prop firm's permission” (pricing FAQ). CrossTrade: “Prop firms set their own rules on automation, copiers, and third-party tools”, and its terms say it “does not verify any Prop Firm's rules on your behalf”. Our PickMyTrade builder page keeps a table of what eight futures firms say about automation, each quoted from the firm.
After you pick
Send a test alert to a demo or sim account inside the trial before anything trades live.
The trials, and where to go next
TradersPost's 7-day trial auto-submits to paper accounts only. PickMyTrade's pricing pages list a 7-day trial with no card (its sign-up screens said 5 days on 11 November 2026, so check the expiry in your dashboard). CrossTrade's 7-day trial opens every feature with no card. For TradersPost's plans and add-ons, use the TradersPost cost calculator; for the three side by side, read TradersPost vs PickMyTrade vs CrossTrade.